The duo compliment each other perfectly with Erin’s clear emotive vocals and crisp rhythms on guitar, blending with [Todd’s] deeper backing vocals and extraordinary guitar and multi-instrument playing.
— L. Paul Mann,
Now, what catches my attention is I can hear every one of these songs on the radio.
— Sean Dennison,
Todd & Erin are a nice detour from conventional pop music...
On Steel Your Nerves, the pair continues to crank out pumped-up pop anthems clearly aimed for the dance floor.
— The Independent